What does the business interruption test case appeal and second test case mean for my business?
Since the initial Business Interruption Test Case heard late last year by the NSW Court of Appeal, there have been significant developments, including an application for special leave to appeal which is currently before the High Court of Australia and the launch of a second test case.
To keep businesses informed, Tim Scott-Young, National Manager, Claims Operations – Marsh and Luke Stratford, Head of Claims Solutions – Marsh recently hosted a ‘Business Interruption Test Case Update’ webinar. This session was held in collaboration with Sophy Woodward, Special Counsel and Richard Jowett, Partner from HFW and aimed to unpack exactly what these developments may mean for businesses who have experienced business interruption losses resulting from COVID-19 restrictions. Our specialists have also outlined the key insights from the session below.
Initial Business Interruption Test Case Update
Second Business Interruption Test Case
View the Replay
Initial Business Interruption Test Case Update
The initial business interruption test case focused specifically on the application of a common insurance policy exclusion relating to the repealed Quarantine Act 1908. In a unanimous decision, the NSW Court of Appeal found in favour of policy holders and held that this exclusion did not apply to listed human diseases under the Biosecurity Act 2015 (Cth). This meant that policyholders have one less hurdle to overcome when presenting their business interruption claim.
Following this decision, an application was lodged with the High Court of Australia for special leave to appeal the judgement of the NSW Court of Appeal.
Back to top of page
Second Business Interruption Test Case
There are also many other considerations relating to the interpretation of business interruption policies. As a result, insurers have commenced proceedings in a second test case in the Federal Court of Australia. This will determine the meaning of various policy wordings, particularly those that relate to an outbreak of disease within a particular proximity to a business and prevention of access to premises due to a government mandate.
Back to top of page
View the Replay
To understand what the business interruption test case appeal and second test case mean for Australian businesses in greater detail, the replay from our ‘Business Interruption Test Case Update’ webinar has been made available for viewing. Our presenters provide:
- An update on the Financial Conduct Authority’s Business Interruption Test Case Appeal Outcome within the UK and what this may mean for Australia
- Overview of the status of the appeal relating to the first test case in Australia concerning the Quarantine Act
- Information on additional test cases within Australia including what types of cases may be heard and what needs to be tested
- Tips on how Marsh can assist in preparing and submitting a claim on behalf of policyholders
Check out the full replay below.
